CUs: A Lower Bar on Qualification Rates – Ask Bruce Coleman, Vancouver Mortgage Broker
Canadian Mortgage News
CMI 101 Series
Dreyer Group 101 Series
Financial FYI Series
First Time Buyers
Home Buying 101
Starting in 2010, lenders had to ensure that borrowers getting variable or 1- to 4-year fixed mortgages could afford payments at the 5-year posted rate. That rule applied to mortgages with less than 20% equity.
In 2012, OSFI asked federally regulated lenders to apply the same rule to all variable and 1- to 4-year fixed mortgages, regardless of equity. But credit unions, which are provincially regulated, were not bound by this guideline.
As a result, some credit unions today let conventional borrowers qualify for variable-rate mortgages using significantly lower rates. That makes it easier to get approved when your debt ratio is above average.
How much easier?
Consider a qualified borrower making $70,000 a year. As of today, that person can get a variable rate mortgage as high as $483,000 at some credit unions. At a bank, he or she would be capped out at roughly $413,000.*
That’s a 17% increase in buying power (or $70,000), simply by choosing a different lender.
Whereas banks must ensure that variable or 1- to 4-year borrowers can afford payments at a posted rate (5.34% today), some credit unions are assessing those borrowers against much lower discounted rates (e.g., 3.69%). That gives CUs a sizable edge with people who want a variable mortgage but can’t overcome the banks’ posted-rate hurdle.
You’d think such a slanted playing field would frustrate federal policy-makers, and perhaps it does. But credit unions are just 12-15% of the market so Ottawa doesn’t view their lending practices as a key threat to financial stability. Moreover, credit unions have a proven ability to judge risk, as evidenced by loss rates that are comparable to the banking industry’s. (Remember also that we’re talking about mortgages with 20%+ down, which are lower risk by default.)
All this said, should you take a variable rate or shorter term if you cannot comfortably afford a 200 basis point rate hike? Probably not. Rates have jumped that much in less than 12 months on numerous occasions (not that anyone is predicting that near-term).
One exception is households who expect a cash flow boost or a significant reduction in monthly obligations soon after closing. In these cases, credit unions perform a valuable service for borrowers who’d otherwise be stuck in a government-imposed 5-year fixed rate.**
Sidebar: This mortgage stress tester can show how your payments change in an adverse rate market.
* Based on a variable-rate mortgage with 20%+ equity, a 25-year amortization, a 39% gross debt service (GDS) ratio and no non-mortgage debt. Debt ratio guidelines vary by lender.
** Or any other term longer than five years. The long-run underperformance of these mortgages, when compared to variable or 1-year fixed rates, is well documented.
“ By Robert McLister, Editor, CanadianMortgageTrends.com”